According to a CPB source, and subsequently the WSJ and others, Yahoo has “settled” with the families of Shi Tao and Wang Xiaoning, the two Chinese users of Yahoo’s email service, whom Yahoo sold out to the Chinese government. Shi, a journalist, and Wang, an activist, were both subsequently “sentenced” to 10 years in a Chinese jail.

The settlement featured the offender-who-got-away-with-it’s favorite phrase, “Terms were not disclosed.”

The two journalists and a family member sued the Sunnyvale, Calif.-based company earlier this year after Yahoo HK, Yahoo’s subsidiary based in Hong Kong, gave Chinese authorities emails containing pro-democracy literature. The jailed journalists alleged in the lawsuit that jailers have tortured them and that Yahoo was responsible.

It goes without saying that Yahoo admitted no culpability. For anything.

So, although it’s hard to say exactly, it seems that what happen was: Yahoo paid the families to stop talking about what Yahoo did to their family members. This is no indictment of the families. At least they made Yahoo pay and have the money to make Shi and Wang’s lives inside possibly less ugly and the families’ lives outside also more comfortable. But no justice was done.

Yahoo got away with it.

Update: Wired quotes “a source at Yahoo” for more vague promises.

(T)he company has been “working with the families, and we’re working with them to provide them with financial, humanitarian and legal assistance.”

Yahoo has also agreed to establish a global human rights fund to provide “humanitarian relief” to support dissidents and their families. The source said that details still have to be worked out.

“After meeting with the families, it was clear to me what we had to do to make this right for them, for Yahoo! and for the future,” said Yahoo CEO Jerry Yang in a statement. “Yahoo! was founded on the idea that the free exchange of information can fundamentally change how people lead their lives, conduct their business and interact with their governments.”

“We are committed to making sure our actions match our values around the world. That’s why we are also working to establish a Human Rights Fund to provide humanitarian and legal aid to dissidents who have been imprisoned for expressing their views online,” he said.

Part of the agreement also allegedly contained the provision that Yahoo “would continue to lobby the Chinese government to release his clients. He said that the terms covered many of the issues discussed in the hearing.” What can you say about something like that?

Update: More coverage from The World and Tech Review.

one

According to Bloomberg and the New York Times, Yahoo! CEO Jerry Yang “apologized to the mother of an imprisoned Chinese dissident during testimony at a heated Congressional hearing probing the company’s role in jailing the man.”

Hang on, now. For a year, Yang has been contemptuously dismissing his company’s actions with a tedious repetition of “respect” for the “laws” of the countries in which it operates. In other words, not only did Yahoo do nothing wrong, it did everything right. Then, when the worm began to turn, he and his shill Michael Callahan unconvincingly began to keen about how they didn’t have all the facts when they testified before Congress last year. And now, there’s something to apologize for?

Due to Yang’s lust for money, in 2005 Chinese journalist Shi Tao was sentenced to 10 years in prison for using his Yahoo mail to send notes outside the country. The Chinese authorities stuck their hand out and Yang couldn’t kiss it fast enough. No legal need to comply with this request, much less a moral or even practical desire to maintain independence. No, Yang and his underlings forked over as fast as possible, in order to pleasure the authorities they believed would help them make yet more money.

Prior to that, in 2002 Wang Xiaoning was arrested for using a Yahoo account to advocate for open elections and other political freedoms in China. In both cases, Yahoo or its subsidiary handed over information it was not legally required to give. And even if it had been required, it could have chosen instead to forgo blood money. It did not.

U.S. Representative Tom Lantos, (D) California, a Holocaust survivor and the Chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, before which Yang testified today, was disgusted.

“A company of Yahoo’s resources should have taken every conceivable step to prevent the automatic compliance with a request from the Chinese police apparatus. To this day, Yahoo has failed to change any of its practices in order to prevent such collaboration.”

“While Mr. Callahan may not have known the relevant facts, other Yahoo employees, in fact, did know the nature of the Chinese investigation against Shi Tao prior to our committee hearing. (Yahoo’s actions were) spineless and irresponsible.”

“”I do not believe that America’s best and brightest companies should be playing integral roles in China’s notorious and brutal political repression apparatus.”

“Much of this testimony reveals that while technologically and financially you are giants, morally you are pygmies.”

“Yahoo shares fell 4.6 percent, or $1.43, to $29.93 in Nasdaq Stock Market composite trading,” according to Bloomberg. Let’s hope the bottom falls out and the price of exchanging lives for yet more money is as high for these Corporate Collaborators as it was for Shi Tao and Wang Xiaoning.

Watch video of the Committee’s meeting here. (If you can. It’s a “.smi” file, whatever that is. Doesn’t work for me.)

Update: Clark sent me a link to The World’s coverage. He also wrote a guest post about it on the Technology Review Blog.

9 com

Support this

good luck finding that needle

Committee Tweets

Posting tweet...

Powered by Twitter Tools

tag cloud

archives

Find us

Facebook

friendfeed

Flickr

Twitter

YouTube

irrepressible.info

Global Voices: The World is Talking, Are You Listening?

RSS The Index on Censorship RSS

RSS The Open Rights Group RSS

Free Kareem


ALERT!! A serious injustice was committed. Please take action now! Kareem Amer, an Egyptian blogger who was imprisoned for exercising his right to freedom of speech, is still in prison and needs YOUR help!
Find out more information by visiting FreeKareem.org or by networking with us.



Kareem has been in prison for:   1225 days.


Flickr photos

Tamer MabroukJames BuckFlag of GuatemalaBlogYoani SanchezLinkedIn